$10 Indian Gold Coin Expected to Realize $500,000+ in Auction

Major Numismatic Rarity Discovered by Heirs of CIA Family.

by Great Collections Coin and Currency Auctions |

Published on November 19, 2026

GreatCollections is auctioning a 1911-D $10 Indian gold eagle graded PCGS MS-65 and approved by CAC — one of the most important numismatic discoveries of the year. The coin, found by the heirs of a former CIA employee, is offered unreserved and is expected to realize $500,000 or more, with bidding closing Sunday, January 10, 2027.

The 1911-D has the lowest mintage of any regular-issue Indian Head eagle struck from 1907 to 1933, and it is the leading condition rarity of the series. No PCGS MS-65 example has been offered at public auction since 2007. In February 2026, the only example graded higher — a PCGS MS-66 CAC from the James A. Stack, Sr. Collection — realized $1,800,000.

Unrecognized for decades, the coin had never been certified until 2026, when it was submitted to Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) and Certified Acceptance Corporation (CAC). The PCGS Price Guide value is $425,000 and bidding is expected to exceed this by the time the hammer falls in the GreatCollections auction.

“The coin was discovered among three dozen common, low-grade pre-1933 gold coins in a safe deposit box. The family inherited the coins from a relative who worked in the CIA during the 1950s — it's amazing how many coin collectors worked in Washington during the 1950s and 1960s. The coin remained ungraded in an old paper envelope until earlier this year, when PCGS graded it MS-65 and it was also approved by CAC,” said Ian Russell, president of GreatCollections.

The Lowest Mintage of the Series

Designed by Augustus Saint-Gaudens, the Indian Head eagle was struck from 1907 to 1933. The Denver Mint produced just 30,100 eagles in 1911, compared with more than 2.3 million there the year before. Much of the mintage is believed to have been melted in the 1930s, and the survivors are mostly circulated or in the lower Mint State grades.

In gem condition the 1911-D is rarer still. PCGS has certified only a handful of examples as MS-65, with a single coin finer, and NGC has graded just one as MS-65 with none finer. Several celebrated Indian eagle collections — including those of Dr. Thaine B. Price and Dr. Stephen L. Duckor — were completed without a gem 1911-D.

A Gem Not Offered at Auction Since 2007

Public offerings of a gem 1911-D are rare enough that each one is a landmark. The last PCGS MS-65 to cross the auction block was the Kutasi Collection coin in January 2007, which brought $195,500 — at the time a record for the date. That record stood until February 2026, when the Stack PCGS MS-66 CAC realized $1,800,000, an auction record for any circulation-strike Indian eagle.

The 1911-D $10 Indian Gold Eagle, PCGS MS-65 CAC — obverse and reverse in GreatPhoto by GreatCollections (Item 2315177).

Auction details: 1911-D $10 Indian Gold Eagle, PCGS MS-65, CAC approved. GreatCollections Item 2315177. Unreserved. Bidding closes Sunday, January 10, 2027. View the coin and bid at GreatCollections.

Looking to buy or sell? If you are looking for key-date Indian gold eagles or other pre-1933 U.S. gold, send GreatCollections your wantlist and we will notify you when matching coins appear in our auctions. Families who have inherited coins — even ones that appear common — are encouraged to have them reviewed before selling. To consign, visit greatcollections.com/sell or call 800-442-6467.

Related Stories (powered by Greysheet News)

View all news