Check Out Books & Supplies at Whitman.com.
View Image Gallery Similar item Image for 1842-C $2 1/2 AU58
us
1842-C $2 1/2 AU58
Auction lot photos of this item graded AU58
Coin Value History
1842-C $2 1/2 AU58
Thank you to our sponsors!
Go check them out!
eBay Whitman CAC ICG Heritage Auctions David Lawrence Rare Coins Stacks Bowers Auctions Great Collections
1842-C $2 1/2 MS

AU58

1842-C $2 1/2

Greysheet & CPG® Price Guide
+0.0%
Greysheet (2026)
$1,234
Wholesale
Subscribe to View Log In
Price History
+0.0%
CPG (2026)
$1,234
Retail
Subscribe to View Log In
Price History

Auction Prices

2 recent AU58 sales, then the closest other results
See all
1842-C Liberty Head Quarter Eagle. Winter-1. AU-58 (NGC).
AU58 NGC
1842-C Liberty Head Quarter Eagle. Winter-1. AU-58 (NGC).
$14,640
Sold 9/2/2026
Stack’s Bowers Galleries
1842-C $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. Variety 1. ...
AU58 NGC
1842-C $2 1/2 AU58 NGC. Variety 1. ...
$12,000
Sold 1/13/2023
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 AU55 NGC. Winter-1, ...
AU55 NGC
1842-C $2 1/2 AU55 NGC. Winter-1, ...
$10,065
Sold 5/1/2026
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 AU55+ PCGS. CAC. Variety 1. ...
AU55 PCGS CAC
1842-C $2 1/2 AU55+ PCGS. CAC. Variety 1. ... CAC approved
$11,400
Sold 9/6/2018
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 MS61 PCGS. ...
MS61 PCGS
1842-C $2 1/2 MS61 PCGS. ...
$21,850
Sold 2/8/2009
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. Variety 1. ...
MS62 PCGS
1842-C $2 1/2 MS62 PCGS. Variety 1. ...
$37,600
Sold 1/9/2017
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Winter-1....
AU53 NGC
1842-C $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Winter-1....
$9,000
Sold 11/13/2025
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Variety 1. ...
AU53 NGC
1842-C $2 1/2 AU53 NGC. Variety 1. ...
$5,047
Sold 10/16/2020
Heritage Auctions
MS63
$8,050
Sold 8/6/2003
R.M. SMYTHE & CO
1842-C $2.50 PCGS/CAC MS65
MS65 PCGS CAC
1842-C $2.50 PCGS/CAC MS65 CAC approved
$182,500
Sold 5/24/2021
DLRC
Subscribe to View Log In

View more data, info, and visualizations. Get access to retail and wholesale pricing as well as auction data.

Auction Prices, Other Grades

Recent public sale records for this item in other grades
See all
1842-C Liberty Head Quarter Eagle. Winter-1. AU-50 (NGC).
AU50 NGC
1842-C Liberty Head Quarter Eagle. Winter-1. AU-50 (NGC).
$7,930
Sold 9/6/2026
Stack’s Bowers Galleries
1842-C $2 1/2 XF40 PCGS. Winter 1....
XF40 PCGS
1842-C $2 1/2 XF40 PCGS. Winter 1....
$5,040
Sold 8/28/2025
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 -- Ex-Jewelry, Repaired -- ANACS. VF30 Details. Mintage 6,729....
VF30 ANACS
1842-C $2 1/2 -- Ex-Jewelry, Repaired -- ANACS. VF30 Details. Mintage 6,729....
$1,860
Sold 8/30/2023
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 XF45 NGC. Variety 1. The 1842-C is scarce in all grades, coming from a mintage of only 6,729 pieces. This exa...
XF45 NGC
1842-C $2 1/2 XF45 NGC. Variety 1. The 1842-C is scarce in all grades, coming from a mintage of only 6,729 pieces. This exa...
$4,800
Sold 10/13/2021
Heritage Auctions
1842-C Liberty Quarter Eagle. EF-45 (PCGS).
XF45 PCGS
1842-C Liberty Quarter Eagle. EF-45 (PCGS).
$3,760
Sold 4/5/2017
Stack’s Bowers Galleries
1842-C $2 1/2 AU50 NGC. Variety 1. ...
AU50 NGC
1842-C $2 1/2 AU50 NGC. Variety 1. ...
$7,638
Sold 9/12/2016
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 VF20 PCGS Secure. Variety 1. ...
VF20 PCGS
1842-C $2 1/2 VF20 PCGS Secure. Variety 1. ...
$1,645
Sold 1/12/2015
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 XF40 PCGS. ...
XF40 PCGS
1842-C $2 1/2 XF40 PCGS. ...
$2,820
Sold 12/2/2012
Heritage Auctions
1842-C Liberty Quarter Eagle. AU Details--Improperly Cleaned (NGC).
1842-C Liberty Quarter Eagle. AU Details--Improperly Cleaned (NGC).
$1,622
Sold 6/29/2012
Stack’s Bowers Galleries
1842-C $2 1/2 VF30 NGC. Variety 1. ...
VF30 NGC
1842-C $2 1/2 VF30 NGC. Variety 1. ...
$1,840
Sold 2/6/2011
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 VF35 PCGS. ...
VF35 PCGS
1842-C $2 1/2 VF35 PCGS. ...
$2,990
Sold 6/2/2008
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 VG10 PCGS. Variety 3-B. Just 6,729 pieces were produced for this challenging Charlotte issue. Well worn with ...
VG10 PCGS
$978
Sold 4/7/2006
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 Fine 15 PCGS. Variety 3-B. Surprisingly well detailed for the grade, especially on the reverse. Reddish-green...
F15 PCGS
$1,725
Sold 4/7/2006
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2 Fine 12 NGC. Issues from the Charlotte Mint ...
F12 NGC
$1,006
Sold 1/10/2004
Heritage Auctions
1842-C $2 1/2
VF25 PCGS
$962
Sold 3/14/1996
Heritage Auctions
Subscribe to View Log In

View more data, info, and visualizations. Get access to retail and wholesale pricing as well as auction data.

Greysheet News

1796 Coin in Post-ANA Auction Rarities Session
1796 Coin in Post-ANA Auction Rarities Session

On September 1, Stack's Bowers conducted a Rarities Night session in California as part of this firm's post-ANA World's Fair of Money® auction extravaganza.

By Greg Reynolds 11/9/2026
Review Held for Dollars, Comic Art Coins and Medals
Review Held for Dollars, Comic Art Coins and Medals

Commissioners reviewed reverse designs for the four American Innovation dollars scheduled to be released in 2028 and obverse and reverse designs for the 2027 issues in the Comic Art Coin and Medal Program.

By Larry Jewett 11/6/2026
The Business of Numismatics: November 2026 Greysheet Editor's Letter
The Business of Numismatics: November 2026 Greysheet Editor's Letter

The rare coin market so far in 2026 has been somewhat volatile, with greater price swings happening over a shorter period of time when compared to historical norms.

By Patrick Ian Perez 11/4/2026
See all

Events

Heritage Auctions: US Currency Tuesday Select Auction
Heritage Auctions: US Currency Tuesday Select Auction Location: Heritage Auctions
Tuesday, September 1, 2026
Heritage Auctions: World Paper Money Tuesday Select Auction
Heritage Auctions: World Paper Money Tuesday Select Auction Location: Heritage Auctions
Tuesday, September 1, 2026
Heritage Auctions: World & Ancient Coins ANA Signature Auction & Platinum Session
Heritage Auctions: World & Ancient Coins ANA Signature Auction & Platinum Session Location: Heritage Auctions
Tuesday, September 1, 2026
See all