Check Out Books & Supplies at Whitman.com.
Indian Cents, Proof (1859–1909) us

Indian Cents, Proof Values

Greysheet & Red Book® PRICE GUIDE

The Greysheet Catalog (GSID) of the Indian Cents, Proof (1859–1909) series of Small Cents in the U.S. Coins contains 250 distinct entries with CPG® values between $100.00 and $156,000.00.

Proof Indian cents were made throughout the duration of the series, which was designed by James B. Longacre and struck from 1859 through 1909. Proof coins, which are struck by specially prepared dies on polished planchets, have been popular with coin collectors since the 19th century. Unlike most proof coins made in the United States since the late 1960s, proof Indian Head cents were made at the Philadelphia Mint, not the San Francisco Mint -- in fact, the first "S" mint Indian cents were not made until the last two years of the series, which were 1908 and 1909.

Most Indian cent proof issues were minted in quantities ranging from about 1,000 to 3,000, with some dates seeing fewer or more pieces depending on demand and other factors. Generally speaking proof Indian cents are scarce across the board with true gem specimens featuring cameo devices considered especially rare. Certified proof Indian cents in the PR63 level or higher are most popular among proofs. The 1864 bronze "With L" proof Indian cent and 1877 proof Indian cent are the scarcest in terms of rarest proof issues. Given that many proof Indian Head "pennies" were saved by collectors, certain dates are actually more common in proof than in similarly well-preserved mint state specimens.
Our Sponsors
1860 1c PR
$680 - $33,600
1861 1c PR
$750 - $33,600
1863 1c PR
$400 - $28,000
Sponsor
$325 - $8,100
$650 - $12,000
$15,000 - $90,000
$30,000 - $78,000
$150.00 - $720
1865 1c PR RB
$500 - $1,848
1865 1c PR RD
$600 - $17,400
$135.00 - $2,140
1866 1c PR RB
$400 - $1,650
1866 1c PR RD
$600 - $35,000
$135.00 - $1,500
1867 1c PR RB
$400 - $3,740
Sponsor Whitman
$165.00 - $1,450
1868 1c PR RB
$230.00 - $1,705
1868 1c PR RD
$340 - $6,600
$350 - $2,160
1869 1c PR RB
$750 - $3,300
$300 - $2,760
$375 - $3,720
1871 1c PR RB
$500 - $5,400
$300 - $2,160
$450 - $3,600
1872 1c PR RD
$750 - $11,400
Sponsor eBay
$170.00 - $3,600
$150.00 - $1,440
1874 1c PR RB
$240.00 - $5,940
1874 1c PR RD
$400 - $18,000
$160.00 - $6,000
$260 - $6,120
1875 1c PR RD
$350 - $24,000
$200.00 - $2,640
1876 1c PR RB
$400 - $6,000
$2,400 - $13,200
1877 1c PR RB
$3,100 - $20,000
Sponsor ICG
$100.00 - $2,040
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1879 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $25,000
$100.00 - $2,040
1880 1c PR RB
$160.00 - $2,640
1880 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $11,500
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1881 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $10,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1882 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $7,200
Sponsor Stacks Bowers Auctions
$100.00 - $2,040
1883 1c PR RB
$160.00 - $2,904
1883 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $27,000
1884 1c PR BN
$100.00 - $5,500
$160.00 - $9,000
1884 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $25,000
$100.00 - $2,040
1885 1c PR RB
$160.00 - $15,000
1885 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $10,800
$100.00 - $10,500
$160.00 - $2,640
$300 - $4,000
$225.00 - $5,000
$300 - $3,600
$400 - $30,000
Sponsor CAC
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $4,600
1887 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $6,600
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1888 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $27,500
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1889 1c PR RD
$260 - $10,800
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1890 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $7,200
$100.00 - $2,040
1891 1c PR RB
$160.00 - $2,904
1891 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $24,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1892 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $10,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1893 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $9,000
$100.00 - $2,040
1894 1c PR RB
$160.00 - $2,904
1895 1c PR BN
$100.00 - $2,244
1895 1c PR RB
$160.00 - $2,904
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
$100.00 - $2,040
1897 1c PR RB
$160.00 - $2,904
$100.00 - $2,040
1898 1c PR RB
$160.00 - $2,904
1898 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $24,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $4,500
1899 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $40,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1900 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $30,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1901 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $30,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1902 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $25,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $6,000
1903 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $25,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1905 1c PR BN
$100.00 - $2,244
$160.00 - $2,640
1905 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $33,000
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1907 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $19,500
$100.00 - $2,040
$160.00 - $2,640
1908 1c PR RD
$220.00 - $7,800
$100.00 - $4,200
$160.00 - $4,200
Subscribe for complete pricing access Subscribe to View Log In

From the Greysheet Marketplace

Live listings from Greysheet dealers
See all

Greysheet News

Historic July 4th Privy Mark 2.5 Ounce Silver Quarters to be Auctioned by Stack's Bowers Galleries Presented on Behalf of the United States Mint
Historic July 4th Privy Mark 2.5 Ounce Silver Quarters to be Auctioned by Stack's Bowers Galleries Presented on Behalf of the United States Mint

The Rarest United States Silver Coin of the 21st Century.

$10 Indian Gold Coin Expected to Realize $500,000+ in Auction
$10 Indian Gold Coin Expected to Realize $500,000+ in Auction

Major Numismatic Rarity Discovered by Heirs of CIA Family.

CAC Coins Bring Premiums in October 2026
CAC Coins Bring Premiums in October 2026

CAC approved and CACG encapsulated coins fared well in public sales during the month of October 2026.

Events

Heritage Auctions: US Currency Tuesday Select Auction
Heritage Auctions: US Currency Tuesday Select Auction Location: Heritage Auctions
Tuesday, September 1, 2026
Heritage Auctions: World Paper Money Tuesday Select Auction
Heritage Auctions: World Paper Money Tuesday Select Auction Location: Heritage Auctions
Tuesday, September 1, 2026
Heritage Auctions: World & Ancient Coins ANA Signature Auction & Platinum Session
Heritage Auctions: World & Ancient Coins ANA Signature Auction & Platinum Session Location: Heritage Auctions
Tuesday, September 1, 2026